I’m a big fan of the Unfiltered Waters podcast. If you don’t already listen to it, I suggest you check it out. I think it’s a must-listen for swimmers, coaches, parents and any swim fan.
Last week, they released an episode where Ariarne Titmus sat down with Katie Hoff to discuss her career and her decision to retire from swimming.
There is one part of the conversation I want to dive into in more detail today (no pun intended!).
Ariarne was discussing her mindset, and specifically how she viewed her mind as her “superpower.” Here’s the interesting thing: while she believes it’s possible to learn tools to build your mindset, in her case she feels she was born with it. She said she has never spoken to a psychologist and “never used sports psych tools.” She was worried that if she did talk to someone, they might change what was working for her.
“I think you can develop your mindset. I think you can 100% learn tools in your life to build a strong mindset, but in my case I believe I was born with it. I have never spoken with a psychologist in my life.” – Ariarne Titmus
Are some swimmers truly born with it?
I believe the answer is yes.
Ariarne is one of them. Throughout my decades around swimming, I’ve observed a handful of other swimmers who also seem to have this “superpower.” They are the ones who seem to perform at their best no matter the circumstances.
From what I’ve seen, some swimmers are naturally “wired” to process information in a way that lets them handle difficult situations effectively. Others may have an innate ability to figure out, through trial and error, which mindset strategies work for them, without even being conscious of it.
Like Ariarne, the swimmers who appear to be “born with it” may resist the idea of traditional sports psychology or mindset work. They don’t want or need someone messing with what’s working. That’s a valid concern. No one wants to mess with success. But I don’t believe that means the “naturals” should leave their minds unexamined.
As proof, look no further than the person interviewing Ariarne: Katie Hoff.
“Natural” skills don’t always hold up under pressure
During the interview, Katie described her younger self as remarkably similar to Ariarne: hard-charging and fiercely competitive. As a young swimmer, she would go up to competitors and ask their times just so she could tell them she was faster. She decided at age 10 that she wanted to go to the Olympics.
She made her first Olympic team at just 15, and that’s when things started to fall apart. All of a sudden, this fierce competitor seemed remarkably vulnerable. In her book Blueprint, Katie describes how “everything about Athens felt different.” She wrote: “I wasn’t in my own bed at night. I wasn’t with my NBAC teammates. I wasn’t with my coach. I wasn’t going home at night to dinners that my mom cooked. There was nothing familiar for me to hang onto.”
Katie came to Athens ranked in the top 8 and a podium hopeful in the 400 IM. Instead, she added 10 seconds in prelims and finished 17th. To make matters worse, she threw up as she got out of the pool.
Her competitiveness didn’t disappear in Athens. What disappeared were the familiar things around her. They had been quietly propping up her mindset, and she may not have realized she was leaning on them until they were gone.
Contrast Katie’s experience with that of Italian swimmer Simone Cerasuolo, who I wrote about in a previous article. In SwimSwam Magazine Simone said leaving Italy to train or race is difficult for him because “the city, the people, the daily rhythms of home are not background details; they are anchors.”
When he qualified for the 2025 World Championships in Singapore, he felt both excited and concerned about racing far from home, because he recognized how important the familiar was to his mindset and, ultimately, his performance.
Simone rose to the occasion and won the world title in the 50 breast. He was able to perform because he recognized in advance that his mindset depended on anchors that wouldn’t be available in Singapore. So he did two things intentionally:
He kept in constant touch with his girlfriend, friends and family from afar. He said they “made him feel at home, even from far away.”
He narrowed his focus to swimming. He stopped thinking about food, routines and any details of his environment he couldn’t control.
The difference between Katie and Simone wasn’t talent or toughness. Simone knew what he was leaning on, so he could plan for losing it.
This isn’t to suggest Katie did anything wrong. She was only 15 when she went to Athens, and more than 20 years ago there were no iPhones to keep her closely connected to her family. Her book also makes clear she lacked support from teammates and coaches that could have helped her recognize and plan for what she was going to face.
Why paying attention matters, even when it’s working
The story of Simone and Katie shows why I think every swimmer benefits from witnessing themselves, including the ones who seem not to need it.
Witnessing doesn’t mean changing what’s working. It means noticing it. What’s going on in your mind before a race? What’s your pre-race routine? What familiar things are you relying on? What do you notice when a disruption happens, and how do you handle it?
When you understand what’s working, it stops being something that just happens. It becomes something you can lean on deliberately. That matters most when the pressure is higher than anything you’ve faced before, or when the familiar things around you are suddenly gone.
That’s also the answer to Ariarne’s concern. Paying attention to what works doesn’t threaten it. Not knowing what’s working is the bigger risk, because then you can’t reach for it when you need it.
It’s for everyone
The takeaway is that every swimmer needs to pay attention to mindset, including the ones who seem to have it all figured out.
If you coach a swimmer who always seems to have it, ask them to reflect on what worked for them after every meet. Understanding the tools and strategies they’re using, even without realizing it, makes it easier to reach for those tools when circumstances change.
If you’re a coach who wants to explore the role mindset plays in your team’s performance, book a Championship Readiness Check.



